Andrew Flintoff’s career numbers are ultimately underwhelming, but against the best team of his era he stepped it up
S Rajesh25-Aug-2009Numbers can never do full justice to Andrew Flintoff: a Test career which fetches 3845 runs at an average of 31.77, and 226 wickets at a touch under 33 will do nicely for most players, but from a player touted as one of the best allrounders of this era, these are somewhat underwhelming. These stats support Peter Roebuck’s assertion – and Flintoff’s own statements – that his career has been more about competence and stout-hearted performances than about sustained out-and-out greatness.There were periods of his career, though, when Flintoff delivered on his promise and then some. The two-and-a-half year period between January 2004 and June 2006 saw Flintoff at his pomp with both bat and ball – his batting average almost touched 40, with three of his five centuries coming then, the bowling average slipped to below 26, with his average wickets per Test exceeding four, and he picked up four out of six Man-of-the-Match awards. He was the only player to score 1000 runs and take 50 wickets during this 30-month period.Unfortunately for him, though, this span only took him through 33 of his 79 Tests. Over the rest of his career, his numbers slipped drastically. In his first 29 matches, he picked up a mere 52 wickets – less than two per game – and needed almost 16 overs to strike, hardly the kind of stats which reflect a potent strike bowler. Similarly, in his last 17 matches, he took only 40 wickets at an average touching 40. During both these periods, his batting came down a few notches from its peak too.
PeriodRunsAverage100sWktsAverage5WIStrike rateFirst 29 Tests (till Dec ’03)120925.7225245.55094.7Next 33 Tests (Jan ’04 to Jun ’06)191839.95313425.80250.8Last 17 Tests (Jul ’06 to Aug ’09)71827.6104039.571802Career (79 Tests)384531.77522632.78366.1It’s impossible to talk about Flintoff without bringing Ian Botham into the picture. Both were flamboyant, capable of changing the course of a game with bat and ball, and both relished the challenges of an Ashes contest more than most. Botham had the better average as batsman and bowler, scoring more than 33 runs per dismissal and conceding less than 29 per wicket. However, the difference was much starker in terms of their abilities to put in major performances: Botham had 12 centuries and an incredible 27 five-wicket hauls, compared to just five and three for Flintoff. Botham also had twice the number of Man-of-the-Match awards – 12 to six.Both enjoyed the Australian challenge – exactly half of those awards for them came against Australia. Botham’s batting average dropped a bit against them, but it was still higher than his bowling average.Most of the stats below favour Botham, but one area in which Flintoff clearly stole a march was in performances against the leading team of the era. In Botham’s case, that team was undoubtedly West Indies, and Botham undoubtedly struggled against them. In 20 Tests, he didn’t score a single century – his highest being 81 – and his 61 wickets came at a relatively high average of more than 35. He did win one match award, at Lord’s in 1984, for scores of 30 and 81 and eight wickets in the first innings, though he leaked 117 off 20.1 wicketless overs in the second innings as West Indies chased down a target of 344 losing only one wicket.On the other hand, Flintoff has done much better against the top team of his era, though he did lead the team to a rather sorry 5-0 thrashing in 2006-07.
TestsRunsAverage100sWktsAverage5WIMoM awardsIan Botham – career102520033.541438328.402712Andrew Flintoff – career79384531.77522632.7836Botham v Aus36167329.35414827.6596Flintoff v Aus1590633.5515033.2023Botham v West Indies2079221.4006135.1831Flintoff’s bowling average against Australia are good enough to win him fourth spot among bowlers who’ve taken at least 25 Test wickets against them since 2000. Only Dale Steyn, Harbhajan Singh and Muttiah Muralitharan have done better, while two other high-class spinners, Anil Kumble and Daniel Vettori, have both been pushed back. Flintoff, though, is the only one among the top seven not to have a ten-wicket haul against them.
BowlerTestsWicketsAverageStrike rate5WI/ 10WMDale Steyn63427.7946.22/ 1Harbhajan Singh137727.8056.07/ 3Muttiah Muralitharan63732.5961.44/ 1Andrew Flintoff155033.2059.22/ 0Daniel Vettori135133.4167.66/ 1Anil Kumble147433.7258.17/ 2Makhaya Ntini155834.7459.22/ 1Merv Dillon72735.8855.90/ 0Jacques Kallis184136.8763.60/ 0Matthew Hoggard123538.1162.81/ 0Head-to-head battlesSome of his best moments came against Australia, so it’s hardly surprising that plenty of Australians figure in the list of batsmen he’s dismissed most often in Tests. His head-to-head stats (only since December 2001) indicate he had his share of victories against top-class batsmen. Matthew Hayden struggled against him in 2005, and had an overall average of 31.33 against him, falling six times in 407 deliveries. Mahela Jayawardene was the other batsman who Flintoff dismissed six times, at an even lower average.Five Australians figure in the top seven, which indicates what a force Flintoff was against them. He was especially effective against their left-handers: apart from Hayden, Justin Langer, Simon Katich and Adam Gilchrist all lost more battles against him than they won.He had some success against another high-class left-hander: Brian Lara was dismissed by him four times in 263 deliveries, and averaged a touch over 27. Stephen Fleming fared worse, scoring 75 runs while falling to him four times.Some of the other batsmen had more success against him, but none more than Michael Clarke, who didn’t fall to Flintoff even once in 375 deliveries (62.3 overs, or Flintoff bowling continuously to him without success for more than two sessions), during which period he scored 195 runs. A couple of left-handers from New Zealand and South Africa played him well too – Mark Richardson and Gary Kirsten faced 200 or more deliveries without surrendering their wicket. Inzamam-ul-Haq, Sachin Tendulkar and Rahul Dravid all averaged more than 50 against him.
BatsmanRunsBallsDismissalsAverageRun rateMatthew Hayden188407631.332.77Mahela Jayawardene151341625.162.65Ricky Ponting226424545.203.19Graeme Smith249436549.803.42Simon Katich134341526.802.35Justin Langer121221524.203.28Adam Gilchrist121186524.203.90Neil McKenzie62129512.402.88Jacques Kallis139372434.752.24Brian Lara109263427.252.48Ramnaresh Sarwan105203426.243.10Stephen Fleming75192418.752.34Damien Martyn60113415.003.18Rahul Dravid154470351.331.96Sachin Tendulkar133342266.502.33Inzamam-ul-Haq86178186.002.89Michael Clarke1953750-3.12Virender Sehwag761270-3.59Mark Richardson782620-1.78Gary Kirsten762000-2.28In the Ashes series Flintoff has generally been a huge force against left-hand batsmen, but overall in his career, he had more success against the right-handers, averaging 27.34 against them (bat runs conceded only, since December 2001). Against the left-handers he was a touch more economical, but conceded more than 36 runs per wicket.
Batsman typeRunsBallsDismissalsAverageRun rateRight-handers4074870914927.342.80Left-handers253057747036.142.62
